International Public Law 2

Teachers

Included in study programs

Teaching results

The main goal of the course is the analysis of specific areas of International Public Law. The aim is to acquaint students with the principles, historical development and legal framework of armed conflict law and international humanitarian law in international relations, clarify the factual background and legal basis of international crime punishment from the Nuremberg Military Tribunal, through ad hoc International Criminal Tribunals in the former Yugoslavia and Rwanda to the International Criminal Court.
Knowledge and understanding: understanding the specific areas of International Public Law, and identifying and critically evaluating the applicable norms in the given areas.
Practical skills: ability to orientate and work with relevant sources and case law of international judicial, arbitration and criminal authorities, argumentation skills.
Competences: understanding the legal context in international relations with the possible application of acquired theoretical experience in practice.

After completing the course, the student should:
- understand the international legal regime governing the use of force in international relations,
- analyze current and past examples of the use of force from a legal point of view,
- critically assess the effectiveness, legal force and enforceability of international rules and decisions of institutions, including the United Nations, the International Criminal Court and international criminal tribunals,
- critically evaluate the problematic nature of the norms of international humanitarian law and international criminal law, resp. understand the limits of the relevant subsectors of public international law,
- to analyze the situation of armed conflict from various aspects (international law, human rights, cultural, from the position of representatives of states and international organizations, etc.),
- understand the applicability of international human rights and international humanitarian law to armed conflicts and deduce from this violations of individual standards in the context of case studies (current and past armed conflicts),
- understand the role and organization of collective security at the international level / understand the role of global and regional organizations, such as UN and NATO in international security,
- effectively manage teamwork,
- draft and structure arguments in written and / or oral form,
- ability to present, defend and debate arguments.

Indicative content

International legal status of state bodies for international relations, jurisdiction and immunities. International Diplomatic and Consular law. UN Collective Security. International Organizations and International Security. The Law of Armed Conflict. War Occupation, Neutrality, state Self-Defense. International Humanitarian Law. Military and Humanitarian Intervention, Responsibility to Protect (R2P concept), Intervention by Invitation. International Criminal Tribunals. International Criminal Court (ICC). Prosecution of Heads of State and International Criminal Tribunals and the ICC.
Transitional Justice

Support literature

ONDŘEJ – ŠTURMA – BILKOVÁ- JÍLEK a kol. (2010): Mezinárodní humanitární právo. C.H.Beck Vydavateľstvo, 2010. ISBN 9788074001857
BROWNLIE, I. (2013): Princípy medzinárodného práva verejného. Vydavateľstvo Eurokódex, 2013. ISBN 9788089447640
ORAKHELASHVILI, A. (2018): Akehurst's Modern Introduction to International Law 8th Edition. Routledge, 2018. ISBN 9780415243568
KOLB, R. - HYDE, R. (2008): An Introduction to the International Law of Armed Conflicts. Hart Publishing, 2008. ISBN 9781841137995
CRAWFORD, E. - PERT, A. (2020): International Humanitarian Law. Cambridge University Press; 2nd edition, 2020. ISBN 9781108727716
International Commission on Intervention and State Sovereignty. 2001 The Responsibility to Protect: Report of the International Commission on Intervention and State Sovereignty, (Ottawa, Ontario International Development Research Centre).
CASSESE, A.(2008): International Criminal Law. Oxford University Press, London, 2008.
SCHABAS, W. A. (2001): An Introduction to the International Criminal Court. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 2001.
WESTERN, J. – GOLDSTEIN, J. (2011): Humanitarian Intervention Comes of Age: Lessons from Somalia to Libya. In: Foreign Affairs, 90:6 (Nov/Dec), pp. 48-59/ VALENTINO, B (2011): The True Costs of Humanitarian Intervention. In: Foreign Affairs, 90:6 (Nov/Dec), pp. 60-75.
Dohovory Ženevského a Haagskeho práva, Charta OSN

Syllabus

1. International legal status of state bodies for international relations, jurisdiction and immunities - State sovereignty / state immunity, the position of the head of state, the immunity of the head of state and its relationship to the state and diplomatic immunity, the Pinochet case. 2. International Diplomatic and Consular law - the international legal status of diplomats, the severance of diplomatic relations, the privileges and immunities of state officials in relation to the issue of armed conflict. 3. UN Collective Security - the dichotomy between the rules applicable to the use of force (jus ad bellum) and the rules applicable to involvement in armed conflict (jus in bello), - the UN Security Council as the guarantor of peace with primary responsibility for peacekeeping and security, - the legal framework for collective security in the context of the UN Charter and links to other international organizations. 4. International Organizations and International Security - the activities of international organizations / peacekeeping missions and their responsibilities in relation to armed conflict, - the role of NATO and regional international organizations in international security. 5. The Law of Armed Conflict - beginning, course or end of armed conflict (core of the problem), - application of the law of armed conflicts - identification of parties to the conflict - also combatants / non-combatants / activities of non-state actors (insurgents, national liberation movements, mercenaries, etc.) and / or terrorists in armed conflict and their status, use of means and methods of armed conflict and identification of legality/ illegality. 6. War Occupation, Neutrality, state Self-Defense - the legal regime of war occupation / war occupation and the protection of human rights, - issues of neutral states / ordinary neutrality, recognized and guaranteed neutrality, - the right to individual and collective self-defense of states. 7. International Humanitarian Law 1 - rules on differentiation, proportionality and precautionary measures, - the penetration of the IHL with international human rights law, - national legal incorporation of the IHL, - the normative framework between the law applicable to international and non-international armed conflicts, - Naval and Air War / IHL and space operations law. 8. International Humanitarian Law 2 - identification of specific issues in relation to armed conflicts - e.g. protection of cultural heritage or environmental protection, humanitarian crisis, situation during the Covid-19 pandemic, etc. (in case of ongoing conflicts), - application of international humanitarian law - protection of victims with emphasis on the protection of women and children. 9. Military and Humanitarian Intervention, Responsibility to Protect (R2P concept), Intervention by Invitation - basic legal and legitimate concepts and principles and situations related to the issue of intervention (military, humanitarian, invitation and R2P concepts). 10. International Criminal Tribunals - historical and legal aspects related to individual criminal liability for crimes under international law, - ad hoc international criminal tribunals: ICTY (International Criminal Tribunal for the former Yugoslavia), ICTR (International Criminal Tribunal for Rwanda). 11. International Criminal Court (ICC) - the establishment of the ICC, expectations and reality, jurisdiction, the role of the Prosecutor and the relationship with the UN Security Council. 12. Prosecution of Heads of State and International Criminal Tribunals and the ICC - immunity of Heads of State and prosecution for international crimes. 13. Transitional Justice - transitional justice from a normative perspective defined by the UN framework, individual forms (truth and reconciliation commissions, reparation mechanisms, institutional reforms, amnesties in post-conflict periods). (Throughout the semester of International Public Law 2, emphasis is placed on the extent and consequences of violations of international humanitarian law and human rights law in many past and present armed conflicts using recent and current case studies - eg conflicts in Libya, Syria, Ukraine , in the Democratic Republic of the Congo, Iraq, Afghanistan, etc., while demonstrating the theoretical level of individual legal institutes on the specifics of individual case situations, eg Iraq and intervention and military occupation, etc.)

Requirements to complete the course

The final grade is based on continuous control of the study during the teaching part of the semester, with a percentage of 40% of the total evaluation of the course (participation 5%, activity / control questions 5%, continuous assignments in the form of presentations 30%). The final evaluation is in the form of a colloquium, where the results of the semester assignment are presented in a team (60% of the total evaluation of the course).

Student workload

student workload: 104 h (participation in lectures 26 h, participation in seminars 26 h, preparation for seminars and elaboration of a semester presentation 13 h, preparation for a colloquium 39 h)

Language whose command is required to complete the course

Slovak

Date of approval: 10.02.2023

Date of the latest change: 18.01.2022